CINEMATIC
TOURISM
Insights

When Did Liking A24 Become a Personality Trait?

At first glance, this A24 meme is poking fun at a familiar type of film fan: the cool kids, some would say, too cool for mainstream film. These are the film fans and cinemagoers who firmly associate themselves with a genre of cool independent films and pride themselves on being separate from mainstream cinema fans, and in a way wearing that as a badge of honour.

The irony is that when grouped together, they in fact all look remarkably alike. Whilst thinking they are part of this A24 subculture, they have developed their own recognisable traits, not so different from the mainstream film fans they pride themselves on being separate from.

Throw in the A24 references, and it becomes a statement about those who have become A24 fanboys or fangirls, for a studio associated with films ranging from The Lighthouse to Midsommar.

For those who look more closely, not all the films in the meme are even A24 releases. Yet it perfectly describes a type of film fan.

The meme adapts the Soyjak caricature, often used to poke fun at consumer tastes and online stereotypes. It was originally posted in 2024 by the movie comedy Instagram page @thefilmmemes.

While the creator is making fun of the stereotype, it is very much coming from inside that same A24 fan tent. It’s a self-aware joke, poking fun at the film community he is part of.

A closer look at the meme
Meme headline: Yeah bro, I hate mainstream cinema
01 / The cool kids. “Yeah bro, I hate mainstream cinema.” The joke starts with fans who pride themselves on different tastes.
Close-up of the similar facial expressions in the meme
02 / The faces. The same expressions, repeated across the crowd. Individuality starts to look remarkably familiar.
A24 tote bags and matcha drinks in the meme
03 / The uniform. A24 tote bags and matcha drinks turn film taste into something you can wear and carry.
Film references held by characters in the A24 meme
04 / The film references. Tampopo and Anora aren’t A24 releases, yet both fit the joke.
Full A24 fandom meme showing several near-identical film fans
05 / Too cool to be different? They pride themselves on being alternative. Put them together, and they all look alike.
1 of 5 · Swipe or use arrows

A24 Fandom

For those looking to understand more about film culture and fandom, this meme is a good example of where a studio itself has a fan base.

Looking at the Reddit A24 forum from 2025, reactions to this meme show a community acutely aware of the complexity of this appreciation of the body of work this studio makes and distributes.

One perfectly sums up how it has become Millennial and Gen-Z coded:

“A24 is one part awesome distributor/studio and one part Millennial & Gen-Z marketing experiment.”
Reddit / r/A24

Whilst agreeing they have released some great films, this Reddit commentator adds that A24’s draw is as much the studio as the films it releases:

“…they’ve built a brand so strong that some fans treat the logo like a stamp of instant masterpiece—sometimes it feels like people are buying the vibe as much as the movie.”
Reddit / r/A24

Another commentator touches on the challenge for a studio like A24 of maintaining its alternative appeal as it becomes increasingly successful and well known:

“I mean it’s the constant paradox. If something is good enough it’s probably going to get popular eventually.”
Reddit / r/A24

Then there are those who throw shade at those who feel A24 fandom gives them some sort of street cred in the film community:

“Men who think they are ‘cinephiles’ for enjoying an A24 movie.”
Reddit / r/A24

There is a consistent appreciation of A24 in this thread, which includes a gentle amount of mocking. What comes through is that the studio has a distinct identity, which influences what it releases, whether it produces or acquires the films:

“They have a good eye for filmmakers with something a little bit different to show. Whether it is a drama, comedy, horror, the films are always worth your while imo.”
Reddit / r/A24

Is it fair to say A24 is now mainstream then? Or just achingly cool?

Some commentators feel the meme perfectly represents the A24 type person they have encountered: “This is so funny… It’s literally how every corny goofy ass looking ‘cinephile’ will talk at the house party.” Others have noticed the abundance of hipster-adjacent traits: “So much mullet, moustache and matcha.”

The criticism from the anti-A24 crowd also highlights the perceived snobbery of some fans, particularly those who pride themselves on being different from mainstream cinema audiences, which our meme skewers perfectly.

One commentator, a fan themselves, believes some are too far into the weeds of it all:

“I really respect A24 for consistently picking up interesting films but hate how some of their fanboys act like they’re intimately involved in the production of every film they distribute.”
Reddit / r/A24

It’s perhaps another familiar trait of fandom: becoming so invested in something that its successes and decisions can feel almost personal.

Others get the mockery of the world they are so deep into: “This image personifies this sub.”

In terms of how mainstream the films have become, some disagree, as they are unlikely to find co-workers or family members who have heard of many of the A24 films: “My entire family has no idea what any of these films are. Just saying!”

Another trait of fandom is that people can become so immersed in something, in this case A24, that they sometimes find it difficult to judge how much of that passion or awareness exists outside their own circle. There’s a contradiction here, too, going back to the meme. Fans can pride themselves on being part of a niche community, whilst also overestimating how widely known that world is outside their own circle.

One Reddit commenter captures this A24 fan bubble perfectly, and how awareness of the films within the community can be vastly different from that among ‘normies’, in a sub-thread about Midsommar:

“I know its well known online but like you ask random people if they heard of it and I guarantee you you’re gonna get blank stares like at least 80-90% of the time lmao.”
Reddit / r/A24

She’s Just a Neon Girl!

She was a NEON girl, he was an A24 boy meme
“She’s a NEON girl. He’s an A24 boy.” Posted by @thefilmmemes, 3 September 2024.

Also in 2024, the same creator posted another meme about the possible relationship between someone who likes A24 and someone who likes NEON, the latter distributor whose output is often confused with A24’s by some audiences. Meant in a humorous way, this meme again perfectly sums up how people can form tribes around the films they enjoy. In this case, it turns film distributors into personality types, and jokes about whether two people with different film tastes would make a good couple.

Hinge-ing on A24 Match

Last but not least, the shorthand of being a fan of A24 has seen its proliferation within dating profiles, as an easy way to hopefully stand out from the crowd and show their film credentials and tastes, for those in the know. Dating app Feeld, in 2025, reported a 65% year-on-year increase worldwide in A24 mentions on profiles. Their data showed the mentions of A24 were particularly associated with straight men aged 26–30.

65%year-on-year increase worldwide in A24 mentions on Feeld profiles, reported in 2025.

An earlier academic study, ‘Cool’ Cinema Sells, cited 2022 Instagram data showing that 61.9% of A24’s followers were male, compared with 38.1% female.

This shows how film fandom and its fans have branched out into a broader world. Does A24 have a more masculine-leaning audience?

A24 fandom vs the Film Bro Meme

Research by Andrew Lynch and César Albarrán-Torres (2026) identifies an interesting tension in some of the A24 memes. While A24’s films encompass a broad range of stories and filmmakers, the researchers argue that the studio’s identity in online meme culture has become “coded as masculine and heterosexual”, frequently drawing on what they call the “film bro” stereotype.

The researchers also dived into how fans themselves contribute to A24’s distinctive identity through memes, humour and online discussion. The studio’s reputation, in the researchers’ eyes, is not simply something created by A24’s marketing and its films. It is also reinforced, questioned and occasionally mocked by the very people who follow its work.

A24 Auramaxxing

Founded in 2012, A24 has established a reputation through films including Moonlight, Lady Bird, Hereditary and Everything Everywhere All at Once. Its AAA24 membership, launched in 2022, extends that relationship beyond the films themselves, alongside a growing range of branded merchandise, from clothing and collectibles to screenplay books and the A24 Zine.

What is particularly interesting about A24 is that the fandom is not just attached to individual films, but to the studio itself. For some fans, the A24 name has become a way of identifying with a particular type of cinema, and communicating something about their own tastes and identity.

Back to our A24 Reddit forum, a big part of the fan base loves how they have carved a middle space beyond the low-budget indie space:

“A good movie is a good movie, and A24 has a ton of hits. It’s not as much as it being mainstream or indie it’s more that we now can have mid budget blockbusters again.”
Reddit / r/A24

In the original meme of A24 tote bags, the joke works because the characters and their film references are so recognisable for those within the tribe as well as those who have encountered A24 fans, even when some of those films featured aren’t actually A24 releases. Fans recognise the stereotype, laugh at it, sometimes challenge it and, in doing so, in the case of A24 contribute to the wider culture surrounding the studio.